Business Spotlight: Humble Pie Butter Tart Factory & Pizzeria celebrates 10 years!

subnav icon More

Congratulations to Humble Pie Butter Tart Factory & Pizzeria who is celebrating their 10-year anniversary in 2020!

Founded in 2010 by owner/baker Michelle MacIsaac, the Humble Pie is a friendly, popular, home-style bakery that offers hearty fruit pies, pastries, savoury meat pies and quiche, breads, and golden-delicious culinary delights - the infamous Humble Pie Butter Tarts! In celebration and recognition of another Muskoka anniversary, the bakery will be introducing a commemorative Group of Seven inspired butter tart this summer. The bakery also offers a variety of fresh and delicious Italian inspired pizzas (gluten and dairy free also available).

At Humble Pie, everyone is welcome! It is recommended to order in advance to ensure you get your favourites. Find them in Baysville at 6 Bay Street, visit them on Facebook at, or by calling 705-224-8278.

Contact Us